News and Vioxx.
By John Dietz -
Email Editor
Date: 23-Aug-2005
Well, the verdict in the Robert Ernst vs. Merck case came out Friday with a $253 million dollar verdict against Merck. For those who have been out of the loop, the widow of Robert Ernst, Carol Ernst, sued Merck in Angleton, Texas claiming that her husband, who used Vioxx, died in 2001 of cardiac arrhythmia, which she feels was caused by the drug. Vioxx, a $2.5 billion dollar blockbuster arthritis pain killer, was pulled off the market by Merck in September 2004.
As most readers know, this is a very high profile case. Before the verdict, Merck was faced with approximately 2,600 filed lawsuits with 4,600 plaintiffs. I’m not a betting man, but I am going to go out on limb here and say those numbers are going to increase.
As many as 20 million people worldwide have taken Vioxx. Friday’s verdict saw Merck’s stock lose $5.2 billion in market capitalization. Merck says it will fight all cases, I believe using the classic scorched earth approach. Merck claims that there is no scientific evidence that Voixx causes fatal cardiac arrhythmia or any other type of death.
The plaintiff’s attorney, W. Mark Lanier, says that Merck knew about the drugs’ side effects and suppressed the information. When interviewed, Lanier said that Merck took the “Three Monkey Approach.” "They covered their eyes because they didn't want to see anything that would hurt the sale of Vioxx, they covered their ears because they didn't want to hear anything that would hurt the sale of Vioxx, and they covered their mouth because they certainly didn't want to say anything that would hurt the sale of Vioxx."
Of course, Merck has consistently denied charges that Vioxx caused deaths. Merck has also denied allegations that it concealed information, noting that the company voluntarily withdrew Vioxx from the market. The post verdict interview with the plaintiff’s attorney is a chilling reminder that there are no real winners. The litigator made Merck out to be a new age Bin Laden, and Merck’s defense team acted like the decision would be overturned on appeal. As my father always says: “It all depends on who’s telling the story!”
Whatever side you fall on, this is not important for our discussion. I don’t think we will know the full ramifications for at least ten years. What is important is that many people’s lives will be affected good and bad. Some Wall Street gurus are saying Merck’s value is going to be a zero. File your claim before there's nothing left, so the pundants say…
The point to the story is that you and I should go a long way to avoid being in front of a contingent fee litigator, judge and jury. Part of planning your life’s work is to limit the downside risk. Any good stockbroker worth a salt will tell you to cut your losses and let your winners run. Asset protection planning is about limiting your downside risk. If you plan for the worst, there is a good possibility that you won’t be sitting where Merck is right now.
RELATED ARTICLES:
ABOUT THIS EDITOR:
John Dietz is a strategic advisor at Trustmakers.com with a passion for client solutions that can encompass your business, your real estate, and your personal assets. Mr. Dietz serves to educate you on the latest in asset protection planning.
08 AUGUST
- Governments Competition And Public Policy
- Kinetic Asset Protection When The Financial Seas Are CALM
- Kinetic Asset Protection Moving To Red Part One
- OVERVIEW
- Asset Protection And Long Term Care
- Kinetic Asset Protection Moving To Red Alert Part Two
- Getting To Know Asset Protection
- Kinetic Asset Protection The Players
- Generational Wealth And Domestic Asset Protection
- NEWS AND VIOXX
- TrustMakers Forms Center
- TrustMakers Site Map
EDUCATION PRODUCTS
Asset Protecion Products
If you are looking for the most important concepts in Asset Protection, this is where to start! If you need to talk intelligently about protecting your net worth or you are a professional this book is for you!
Asset Protecion Courses
Know what your Advisor knows. Buy our downloadable Asset Protection Planner Course. Protect yourself like the pros!.
Asset Protection in a Nutshell
Clear, concise and straight forward, this e-Book will help you make sound decisions with your business and personal assets..
Protecting Assets - 10 Session Seminar
This downloadable e-seminar will give you straight forward asset protection advice you can implement now! One of the best seminar courses available!
Advanced Estate Planning
The key to a solid Asset Protection Plan is the Estate Plan. This downloadable e-module will help you sort through the many tax mitigation and estate planning strategies helping you make sure your wishes are carried out. Learn succession planning the right way and protect your wealth for generations to come!



















